• Sovereign Vibe
  • Posts
  • Rise of the yuan? Not so fast đź’´ đź’¶ đź’·

Rise of the yuan? Not so fast đź’´ đź’¶ đź’·

The yen, euro, sterling, CAD & AUD are displacing the dollar by even more.

In this edition, I spotlight the dollar’s status as a reserve currency for the world’s central banks. Spoiler: the rise of China’s yuan is overblown.

Russia’s central bank “prefers” yuan, central banks are buying more gold, BRICS is setting up a digital currency payments system, Brazil has launched an anti-dumping probe against China, EMDEs are undermining multilateralism in the WTO, Zambia finally gets a deal, and more.

Spotlight: De-dollarization

Berkeley-based economist and titan of the profession Barry Eichengreen notes that the dollar’s reserve currency status is continuing to erode in favor of “non-traditional reserve currencies”. But looking closely at the same recently-released IMF data through Q4 2023 paints a more nuanced picture.

At end-2016, the IMF reclassified yuan holdings from “other” to its own explicit category, so I’ve calculated cumulative changes from Q1 2017 onwards:

  • While the USD’s share in international reserves holdings have dropped by about 7 percentage points since then…

  • …the biggest beneficiary is neither the yuan nor “other” currencies…

  • …but in fact the yen.

  • The yuan has increased its share by about 1 percentage point…

  • …but the euro, pound, and Australian & Canadian dollars have seen their shares increase as well, for a combined total of over 2 percentage points.

So the shift away from the dollar is just as much - if not more - about a rotation into G7+ currencies as it is towards the yuan and other non-traditional reserve currencies. I’ve written previously about how a sizable chunk of Russia’s reserves have been held in Japan and how GBP, AUD, and CAD have been eating up some of the USD’s share.

De-dollarization

  • Russia’s central bank says it has no choice but to put more of its reserves into yuan, which is pretty dire. Small wonder that a larger share of these have actually been in gold rather than CNY.

  • The World Bank recently highlighted how central bank net gold purchases are on the rise:

  • In other news and as part of their efforts to decrease their dependence on the USD, the BRICS group is planning on creating a blockchain-based payment system for yet-to-be-created digital versions of their currencies, but this is more analogous to SWIFT than a new currency.

Deglobalization

  • Demonstrating the limits of the BRICS grouping, Brazil has launched anti-dumping probes against China amid soaring imports. If this is what intra-BRICS cooperation looks like, with friends like this, who needs enemies?

  • With Trump potentially returning to the White House next year and Biden having maintained his predecessor’s protectionist policies, what of the future of US multilateralism?

  • Many developing countries have concluded - probably rightly - that the World Trade Organization doesn’t have much to offer them and are now undermining multilateralism there even more than the US is.

  • There are many gaps in the sanctions architecture that Hamas manages to exploit as it raises money for its $500mln investment portfolio.

Sovereign debt

  • After three miserable years of delays due to obstructive Chinese creditors and a lack of clarity over so-called “Comparability of Treatment” rules, Zambia is at last entering the final stages of its Common Framework sovereign debt restructuring.

  • World Bank experts behind the widely-used International Debt Statistics database discuss the shambolic state of sovereign debt transparency. For the G20’s Common Framework debt restructurings, i.e. Chad, Ethiopia, Ghana & Zambia, debt records were “incomplete and often inaccurate” and “Excel spreadsheets had to be manually reconciled - a months-long process that significantly delayed restructuring negotiations.” What a mess.

  • Here is a helpful summary of the state of ongoing sovereign debt restructurings:

  • In Suriname, the IMF Board has approved the Fifth EFF Review. There has been progress on debt restructuring with official and private creditors, though domestic debt arrears need to be cleared.

Thank you for reading the latest edition of the Sovereign Vibe newsletter! Send through your comments and any topic suggestions you have in mind.

Make sure to check out the Sovereign Vibe blog and other editions of the newsletter.

Reply

or to participate.